Get Your Strategy On
I just got off the phone with Maxtor for at least the sixth time. Honestly, I’ve lost count of all the calls I’ve had to make. In February, I purchased their OneTouch II drive. For the record, you don’t want to purchase this drive. It’s been nothing but problems. The original hard drive didn’t work using the software they shipped with the drive. I had to call tech support and they made me install an older version of the software to run the backups. Of course, the older version eliminated the "one touch" feature which was one of the reasons I purchased the drive.
With that modification the backups worked for a while, but then my computer stopped recognizing the drive. After another tech call, they finally determined that the drive was bad and I needed a replacement.
After receiving the replacement drive, I again had to connect with tech support to try to get the hard drive to work on my system. (I have a Dell system that’s only about a year old by the way. It’s not like I’m trying to make it work on some old, no-name computer system.) Yesterday, I finally thought we were up and running. The test backup actually worked. But, this morning, I woke up to find that the scheduled backup failed. And, the computer stopped recognizing the drive…just like the first drive.
I called Maxtor back again this evening for tech support. They had me change the power management settings on my computer, plug the drive into a wall outlet instead of my surge protector and reboot the computer and the drive. The computer still doesn’t recognize the drive. And, after three months, I still don’t have backups. (Having thought I lost all my pictures of our daughter a few months ago, the thought of no backups really freaks me out.)
The Maxtor tech support people asked me to email them system files from my computer to trouble-shoot the issue. Rather than continuing to deal with this mess, I asked if they would just refund me the money if I shipped them back their two hard drives that don’t work on my Dell computer. They wouldn’t do that. So, I’m stuck with no backups and two Maxtor hard drives that don’t work on my system.
Frankly, I’m tired of messing with it. I’ve already invested too much time in this. It’s looking like I’m going to have to eat the $212 I paid for the drive and go purchase another hard drive. I don’t see why Maxtor is making this my problem. It seems like if their hard drive doesn’t work on my newer Dell computer running the most recent version of XP, the fact that their hard drive doesn’t work is actually their problem not mine.
Anyone had a better experience with an external hard drive from another company that I should check out? Looks like I need to go shopping again.
Tony Morgan is a pastor and the Chief Strategic Officer at NewSpring Church where he develops creative solutions for communications, technology and NewSpring Ministries--the church's ministry that equips other church leaders.
[read more...]
Anne Jackson
May 10th, 2006 at 7:48 pm
I don’t think it’s your external - I think it’s the fact you’re using a PC :)
Shellie
May 10th, 2006 at 7:57 pm
I think Maxtor is the problem. This company has always produced a sub-par hard drive in my opinion. I have very frequently had to replace Maxtor drives for friends and at work. I just won’t buy them anymore.
You can by an external housing for any standard hard drive. Western Digital makes the best hard drive in my opinion. I just ordered a great one for my Tivo from http://www.zipzoomfly.com
Now, you will loose the one touch option with this solution, but I’m certain you will have several years of safe file keeping and plently of room to grow on that drive.
I’m sure Jason would have some great insight into this.
Chuck M
May 10th, 2006 at 9:22 pm
Dude! I am not the only one with the same problem. These things suck big time. I had to copy everything on my computer to 10 CD’s last week when my laptop took a dump. Big help the one touch was. Feel your pain.
Tim Stevens
May 10th, 2006 at 9:29 pm
I use the Western Digital “My Book” 160gb version. Picked it up a couple months ago online from Bestbuy.com.
Richard H
May 10th, 2006 at 9:39 pm
Sounds like Maxtor doesn’t want any repeat business.
Derek
May 10th, 2006 at 10:13 pm
I’ve had bad experiences with Maxtor drives going bad early. I’m not surprised that their external enclosures are junk. I’ve never had a problem with a Western Digital or Seagate drive.
I have an external Lacie drive that I use quite heavily, and it works flawlessly. Haven’t had a single problem connecting it to any of the four computers I hook it up to.
The other thing to do is grab a cheap 2.5″ enclosure (you can get them for about $15), and use an old laptop drive. I do that for personal files and it works great, and actually fits in my laptop case.
Becky C.
May 10th, 2006 at 10:50 pm
Our Maxtor bit it a couple of months ago and I nearly lost a year and a half worth of pictures! John DeBoer wrote about it and what he had to go through to fix it on his blog HERE
You can bet I won’t be running out to buy another Maxtor! Go get em, Tony!!
Bob Franquiz
May 10th, 2006 at 11:45 pm
Tony,
I have a Mac, but I use a Lacie external and it has been great.
Josh
May 11th, 2006 at 1:43 am
I’m with Bob. I’ve had two LaCie external drives; haven’t had a problem from either one.
I did have a Maxtor external drive before it led me to buy my first LaCie.
Peter Webber
May 11th, 2006 at 7:48 am
Any internal Hard drive can be used as an external drive with a simple case that will cost you less than 30$
for example, this 100$ 320gb drive:
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.asp?Item=N82E16822144392
Insert it into this $20 External USB Enclosure:
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.asp?Item=N82E16817155515
and you’ve built your own external backup drove for $125 plus maybe $10 for shipping.
now what about software you ask? Easy, for a simple backup of your Entire Main Hard Drive (we’ll call it C:) to your backup drive (we’ll call it E:) the DOS command is
xcopy C:\*.* E:\*.* /c /h /e /r /k /y
this can be automated by creating a ‘batch file’ (using notepad.exe, type that text and save as ‘backup.bat’) once you have your batch file, use windows’ built in scheduler to run the batch every day/week/month/year (whenever you want).
your files will appear on the backup drive EXACTLY the SAME as the files on your main drive. . .
if you want some additional info/help feel free to drop me an email
peter@peterwebber.net
J.C. Jennings
May 11th, 2006 at 12:22 pm
:)
First the HP All in One
Now the hard drives…..
Tony, Maybe it’s just your magnetic personallity that doesn’t get along so well with technology?
Since the hard drives don’t work and you can’t return them, I can’t wait for the pictures of newfound ways the family put the hard drives to use.
I concur with the previous post with buying an internal drive and an enclosure. Get Jason to put it together for ya, it’s quick and easy. I had to do this recently for my Western Digital that died on me right after the 1 year warranty. Unfortunately they just don’t make things the way they used to.
Anne Sam
June 11th, 2006 at 1:20 am
I had exactly the same problem and stumbled across your site because I was trying to figure out how to get my Thinkpad to recognise the Maxtor One Touch II 300GB drive.
All 78GB of music I converted from CDs is in the drive! ARgh!
medah4rick
July 2nd, 2006 at 5:23 am
hey there. i just stumbled on to your site because my one touch II external also went bad.
the d#$% thing all of a sudden stopped being recognized as a external drive. im not too sure of the root of the problem but i have some hunches as to why but we wont get into that here.
anyway i have the 500gb version and had my entire life saved in that baby and i didn’t want to wait for tech support. so i opened up the external case and removed the hard drive. its actually a DIAMONDMAX 10 pata133 model #: 6L500R0. anyway i put that hard drive into an external enclosure that i had laying around but it still wasn’t recognized. so then i set it up inside my computer via ata cable and it was recognized! anyway i set up xp on the drive and now i have a 500gb internal. o well better than nothing.
weird thing now is that NONE of the hard drives i have laying around when connected with my external case can be detected. somehow the motherboard is affected to not recognize any hard drives via usb (even on fresh xp installs) or both my external hard drive enclosures are now somehow fried???
thanks maxtor
medah4rick
July 2nd, 2006 at 5:27 am
o yeah just in case. this could be a longshot but perhaps others can add what they were doing before they started running into these problems.
i was trying to install windows vista beta. and had just installed windows media player 11 beta. playing dvds from the one touch II.
J. SanMateo
July 12th, 2006 at 1:58 am
Just had a Maxtor One Touch II 300GB drive crash on me after one week of transferring data. Ahhhhhhh!
Rio
August 20th, 2006 at 3:28 pm
I don’t have a one touch, but I am having the same drive recogniction problem with my maxtor drive. It’s a 80GB, basic external. The last thing I can remeber doing that might have had any impact was installing a USB blue tooth adapter. Once my Win XP Pro maching wouldn’t recognized, I tried another machine, but with no luck.
I’m hoping a new enclosure might help, but we’ll see when it gets here in a few days.
Mahtiaivo
September 19th, 2006 at 5:34 am
I never had any problems with Maxtor products, ever cam to your mind that your USB is broken (hardware or software wise)
I got 3 Maxtor One Touch and 2 Maxtor One Touch II and they all work fine, never had any troubles with them.
medah4rick
October 16th, 2006 at 6:10 am
i now fully believe that windows vista installation with my shuttle pc inadvertantly damaged the usb enclosures (the one that came with my 500gb one touch and a 2nd generic brand).
reinstalling xp and buying a new enclosure for my maxtor worked.
L@tino
October 28th, 2006 at 6:59 pm
Same problem here, got a Maxtor one touch from Tiger Direct, install the thing (it looks cool on top of my case),filled up with a bunch of files and family pictures preparing for a reformat, and all of a sudden… after a week or so … just disappeared from xp and never to be found again. BUAAAA!
Still working on it and hoping to regain control of the beast one day, but all I can find in related forums is all the same litany. I can feel the pain with you guys.
And by the way, still seating on top of my case, but looks less cool that appeared at first, now I see it more like a piece of crap.
Kym Charlesworth
October 31st, 2006 at 6:45 pm
I have never had any trouble with the One Touch II in terms of being seen by XP Pro although I don’t use the Dantz Retrospect Backup software at all. Having said that, what a crap company Maxtor is. There are NO drivers for this thing on their web site so one has to lug around their stupid CD because without the special drivers the drive can’t be seen by the OS. I’ve just loaded Vista Business at work and yep, you geussed it, the drivers from the Maxtor installation CD install but nevertheless I can’t see the drive in Vista. Key in “Vista” in the maxtor web site and that generates just 1 hit - an article about the Seagate takeover. What a joke.
Mafelix
February 7th, 2007 at 7:25 pm
I feel your frustration. I’ve been dealing with Maxtor for almost a year with a fraked up external drive that bit the dust after 80Days. See my full story at http://www.maxaflaw.tk
I’m still fighting for a replacement drive cus I had to break the warranty to get my data off it through a qualified local tech which cost me $180 instead of the quote from their company of $1600. I’m just a student and couldn’t afford that, and because I didn’t go through their company warranty was Void, but after fighting (and creating http://www.maxaflaw.tk) I managed to convince them. That was 3months ago, now I’ve sent the drive back for replacing I keep getting we’ll be sending the replacement out shortly, within 24-48hr! That was 1 -1 1/2 months ago.
I won’t be buying another Maxflaw drive again. The drive packed up in July last year, its Feb now and no replacement yet!
Mafelix
February 7th, 2007 at 7:42 pm
http://www.maxaflaw.tk
or
http://www.maxflaw.tk
Works ;)
Email me your comments and I’ll include them on the site
Birdie
March 21st, 2007 at 1:17 pm
I don’t think it is your maxtor..I think it is your DELL computer. I had the same problem with a Maxtor hard drive, bought a new western digital e book and had the same problem…fortunately I sent my maxtor to my brother to take a look and see if he could retrieve the pics and data on it. He said the DRIVE was fine, it was the HOUSING that was the problem. The only thing common to these two externals that I had is my DELL pc. DELL suggested I REINSTALL WINDOWS - DELL IS FULL OF SUGGESTIONS…. NOT SOLUTIONS.
You might want to get a new housing for your external and see if you are able to get to your pictures.
Mine are now all backed on CD’s
kevster1976
March 21st, 2007 at 11:56 pm
ive had a maxtor one touch 2 USB 300gb for over a year and had no problems with it. untill now!!
it recently had a power surge and now it wont turn on at all. the light on the power pack stays on when plugged into a power socket, but when i turn on the HD the light blinks.
ive determined that the fault lies within the HD because it does not spin up.
i went to the website and emailed them, but i am waiting on their reply to see wat can be done.
my dilemma is that i dont wanna lose all my backed up files on it, so i want to know if anybody outhere has taken theirs apart and saved all their files by connecting it direct to a pc? sending this HD off to maxtor is gonna cost a fortune! thats if it can be repaired!
someone please help!!! i dont care about the HD, i just wanna rescue my files.
some one out there must have the “knowlegde”
medah4rick
March 24th, 2007 at 6:38 pm
kevster. from my earlier posts i can confirm that i was successfully able to open the enclosure and retrieve the hard drive.
what i did then was simply connect the hard drive through a standard ide cable on my desktop pc.
i installed xp on the drive itself. later i transferred all the files to another drive.
eventually i reformatted the drive and was successfully able to fit the drive into a usb 2.0 enclosure. so my maxtor one touch is back but on a different enclosure.
David
April 4th, 2007 at 9:12 pm
now how did you get in the case? mine isn’t a one touch, but a normal grey external drive that I can’t get into becuase there are no screws…
Stephen
April 7th, 2007 at 7:13 am
Same Issues Here:
When the external one touch drives first came out, our network consultant recommended one as an easy means of making a portable backup copy of data. We added 2 drives to our office network and I added a 300GB Maxtor One Touch II to my home network.
After having no success at using the one touch feature, I abandoned it and just partitioned my home net drive into two partitions and manually made coipes of my data files. It seemed to work fine for while. BUT THEN, after not using the drive for almost 1 year, I tried to turn it on. It was still setup in the same place with wires attached just as it was left originally. AND GUESS WHAT? Windows XP Pro no longer recognized the drive!
So I tried plugging the One Touch into a new portable notebook. XP did recognize that a USB device was plugged in and was able to load drivers, but the OS did not recognize the disk. And of course, ALL OF THE BACKUP DATA ON BOTH PARTITIONS IS NOT ACCESSIBLE!
I’ll never again rely on MAXTOR ONE TOUCH again to safely save any type of backup data!!!
More importantly, we will find another alternate method of making an offsite triplicate copy of our important home and office data!
If anyone has found a solution or means to have Windows XP recognize the Maxtor One Touch II 300GB drive after its demise, please let me know.
Ramu
April 7th, 2007 at 9:19 am
I’ve had similar problems with my Maxtor Onetouch3 external drive — windows would just stop recognising the drive all of a sudden. I tried reconnecting the firewire cable back into my laptop while the Maxtor was still on and this seem to have helped. Windows does stop recognising it once in a while but that happens a lot less frequently now.
Alchemize
April 15th, 2007 at 1:49 pm
Try this…
http://www.yan-ke.com/maxtor_corruption.html
Fabo
August 15th, 2007 at 6:37 am
Hi,
My Maxtor 250GB External Hard drive has been plugged to a 19v power supply instead of to a 12v. The hard drive light went on and then off and know would not work at all.
Do you know if there is some fuse inside or how to open the case. I’ve tried but I couldn’t managed to. Can you help me?
Many thanks
Model (Maxtor External HArd Drive Personal Storage 3200)
Mike Gerstner
August 16th, 2007 at 9:12 pm
External Hardive recognition:
For Windows 2000 and XP:
Right click on My Computer.
Choose Manage (This will open the Computer Management window).
Go to the Storage category and select Disk Management
Right click the new drive (usually listed as Hard Disk 1) and “initialize”
You now have the option to partition and format the drive.
The default settings of Primary Partition and NTFS- Quick Format are recommended for most users.
Enjoy your new drive.
http://computershopper.com/forums/archive/index.php/t-11.html
eric
November 10th, 2007 at 10:11 pm
i will agree with everyone, i bought a maxtor one touch to store photo’s on , after 5 weeks it just quit working . it gets no power and wont turn on . really wish i knew how to get my pictures off of it .
tm
November 19th, 2007 at 5:20 pm
I am so glad I’m not alone, as I’ve had pretty much the same experience as so many of the other posters. Years of photos — weddings, vacations, etc - are gone.
If anyone can guide me on how to open the enclosure and retrieve the hard drive, I’d try anything at this point.
I, too, am using a Dell :(
volkltecnica
November 29th, 2007 at 3:59 pm
I have a maxtor 500 external drive that my son plug a power converter in that had the incorrect voltage and I hope only broke a surge protector in, does anyone know how to get the drive out and or what to do. Maxtor wants $1600 for what is proable $2 worth of hardware. Please send me good news.
Becky
December 10th, 2007 at 11:38 pm
Wow. I just found out this morning my MAXTOR ONE TOUCH III was not working and I had ALL of my photographs in this external hard drive. After talking to Seagate about my warranty (this unit is less than 5 months old) and having them transfer me to Data Recovery (quoted $700-$1900), I decided to go online and see if there was help. I opened up my external drive unit, removed the drive, plugged it into my computer, and now I have an internal drive with ALL of my pictures intact. I voided the warranty on the drive, but who cares, it saved me the megabucks the recovery people would be asking for, and I guarantee, they wouldn’t say it would be the lesser price. Thanks for all your help.
Diana
December 19th, 2007 at 4:23 pm
I’m wondering if someone here can help me.
Unit: Maxtor One Touch II
If I’ve previously backed up my harddrive (C:) onto the Maxtor via the Retrospect sofware, is there any way I can retrieve that data (from the “Restore Points”) without having to use the Retrospect software?
Thanks, in advance.
BigD
December 22nd, 2007 at 2:13 pm
I have a Maxtor 160GB Onetouch firewire and USB2 external that went out on me. Before it went out, my wife said it told her there was a window that opened saying there was a bad cluster in my photo files. After that, it wouldn’t open the drive. It showed it as being there, with 100% free space!! It was over half full of photos, music, movies, and other programs. Many years of data is now lost in the drive. When trying to open it now, it says it’s not formatted and asks if I want to format it!! Knowing better then to click yes, I took it to a local tech to try recovering it. He had no luck, told me I could go to one of the big name recovory sites and pay $2000. It has worked fine as an extra storage space for about 4 or 5 years. I got it because I had a storage problem on my old computer. I don’t want to lose all the files I have on it, but don’t have an extra 2G’s laying around to have it done for me, so I will try installing it inside the computer like some of you have to see if it will work for me also.
Bisc
December 22nd, 2007 at 7:14 pm
2 Step Solution for XP users:
Part 1:
Go to
Control panel -> Performance and Maintenance (cannot be in classic view to see this link) -> Administrator Tools -> Services -> Universal Plug and Play
If Universal Plug and Play is set to manual switch to automatic.
Part 2
Double Click Safely Remove icon on the bottom right-> Select device->click Properties -> click Volumes -> click Populate -> hit OK
It should show up now. In the future when you turn on or connect your hard drive. It may take a few minutes to show up.
djani
February 13th, 2008 at 5:16 pm
so…as far as I knew my 300Gb Maxtor OneTouch III Firewire400/USB 2.0 worked fine. then, I went to turn it on the other day and NOTHING HAPPENED! I checked the power cord because I thought I’d unplugged it by accident maybe. no luck…it won’t turn on at all, doesn’t make a noise…doesn’t do anything when I flick the switch.
I’m glad I came across this site because I searched and haven’t been able to find anything on the net that will help me out. my problem seems to be similar to that of volkltecnica. not sure if he/she or anyone who was able to fix theirs will read this. but, how does one go about removing the “hard drive” from the unit and plugging it directly to the computer??? I certainly can’t pay the money that I’m sure I will be quoted if I try and take it to a tech place to recover the info, but I do have a lot of important/irreplacable stuff that I’d like to recover onto a new (not Maxtor!) hard drive. Anyone with any tips/links on how to go about this? I’d appreciate it much
djani
February 13th, 2008 at 7:52 pm
sorry, it was Becky who’s comment seemed similar to my experience
jwilkins
February 29th, 2008 at 5:43 pm
i have a maxtor onetouch III 500gb external hard drive that i bought from someone and didnt get the drivers for it. i was able to get windows xp to recognize it with the use of seagate diskwizard. i had it attached with a usb 2.0 cable, and bought a firewire cable for it today. the salesman said that the only down side to firewire was that it killed the hot swap feature, but i dont hot swap my peripherals anyways. so when i attached the firewire cable, my computer went thru a installing new hardware stage, but couldnt locate a driver, so it left it in windows manager with a hilited question mark. my computer still recognizes the hard drive though, i have another “other devices” dialog with the question mark in it….what do i have to do to satisfy this request, and keep my external hard drive operating?
thanks so much!!
johnny